Quote:
Originally Posted by Lesley D
It's a very real reality and that's why the Latino umbrella term often makes no sense but it's marketable. It's obvious what the cultural and linguistic links are between the individual ethnic groups but let's face it what do many of these groups have in common?
...
You know how the saying goes: 'hablamos el mismo idioma' but it's more than just that.
-LDG.
|
As I stated in my initial response here, there also exist a debate on whether the Hispanic label is also appropriate, in fact if categorizing various peoples from Latin America into one group makes much sense at all.
Of course, to many of us the term Hispanic does not makes sense, at least not in the way it's used in the United States.
In the US, a Hispanic is someone who comes from a Spanish speaking country in Latin America.
However, in much of Latin American and even in Spain, Hispanics are only people who have full or partial Spanish blood. This would make descendants of Spaniards Hispanic as well as mestizos and mulattos whose European ancestry is of Spanish decent.
Simply being born in a country where the culture is Hispanic is not enough to consider someone Hispanic, such person has to have either full or partial Spanish blood in them.
For this reason many Latin American peoples find themselves with a dilemma when traveling or moving to the U.S.
Example, a person who was born in a Hispanic Latin American country, but has middle eastern or Italian or French or is full Amerindian or perhaps is full African will not be considered Hispanic.
Such person will have a Hispanic culture, but that does not makes them Hispanic per se and usually they don't identify as Hispanics. However, when they travel to the U.S., suddenly they are seen and expected to identify as Hispanic for merely being born in a Spanish speaking Latin American country.
This is the main reason why many Argentinians, for example, don't consider themselves to be Hispanic. Many of them have European ancestry that are not Spanish (ie. Italian, German, French, etc) and thus, they consider themselves Argentinians but not Hispanic. Once they arrive in the U.S., the term Hispanic becomes a dilemma for many of them who in fact are not Hispanic, but are from Hispanic Latin American countries.
Similar experiences occurs with full blooded Amerindians from Mexico and/or Guatemala.
Beyond this there is also the prevailing notion that the word Hispanic means being a mestizo. Usually, Americans think of Hispanics as having mestizo features and puts Hispanics who are either of European, African or Mulatto ancestry into an odd position.
Personally, I think they should simply label people by nationality or, even better, stop labeling people.
-NALs