I have done two trips to Saona. While I loved the first excursion and it was enough to get me to go back, a bit of research led me to an even better one!
I have pictures of both days posted at
http://community.webshots.com/user/kaki333
The first trip was using a speedboat and catamaran and was run with through a tour bought at an AI. We left Bayahibe at 10:30 a.m. and returned to Bayahibe at 4:30 p.m. Those pictures are at
http://outdoors.webshots.com/album/489092643CrzWYX
The second trip was bought through Seavis in Bayahibe. We left Bayahibe at 8:30 a.m. and hit all of the stops of the day before or after the major tour companies so were alone at each spot (but one). This tour was a bit custom-made for me and cost $10 more than the Saona-Catalinita tour sold from their website at
http://www.seavisbayahibe.com/excurs...a_catalina.htm Pictures from that day are posted at
http://travel.webshots.com/album/550135582VbyNRT
The catamaran tour which stops at the Piscina Natural and a short stop at a deep water snorkel site off the tip of Bayahibe doesn't offer all that much for snorkeling and if you went on this tour expecting a big day of snorkeling you could be sorely disappointed. A great day, but snorkeling isn't the focus.
I am looking at spending some time next spring at Villa Iguana in Bayahibe. They offer a room for all needs from a penthouse suite with private pool all the way down to a room with a only a fan.
http://www.seavisbayahibe.com/Rooms_...n_Bayahibe.htm The hosts at the Villa are also very knowledgeable about local fishermen and residents and have recommended a contact to me if I wanted the use of a boat. You can e-mail them from their site and ask for that info too.
I agree with the comment about weekday vs. weekend. There are 1000 passengers a day being processed to the islands out of the Bayahibe bay. Each and every day. AIs book starting whatever day of the week their contract with the tour operator is. I have booked for travel on a Thursday, Saturday and Sunday. In 2007 I travel on Mondays and Fridays. They don't turn over a whole hotel on Saturday, though it remains the busiest day.
Kaki