'Barrio' - a dominicanismo?

[qgrande]

I did a search for 'barrio' in the Spanish101 section, and lots of references to 'barrio' as in 'barrio Spanish' vs. 'correct' Spanish, but what about the word barrio itself? Is the negative connotation a dominicanismo?
I knew that while in the DR 'barrio' and 'being from a barrio' has a negative connotation, in Spain 'barrio' has a more neutral meaning of 'neighbourhood' or urban district. I thought it was an Iberian vs. South American Spanish distinction.
But recently I spoke with some Mexican students and learned 'barrio' is a neutral word in Mexico too. And today I read Isabelle Allende (Chilean) writing about a childhood move to one of the wealthy upperclass 'barrios' of Santiago (de Chile), using that word.
So, I wondered, is the use of 'barrio' with its meaning as a poor working class neighbourhood and negative connotations - as it is used frequently here in the forums - specifically Dominican, or are there more countries where it has that meaning?
Just curious, and it's one of those words that can lead to faux pas in certain situations...

[Chirimoya]

In the DR it can also be used in a neutral sense. Poor neighbourhoods are known specifically as "barrios populares". You can use barrio to mean both things in several other countries, in my experience, and whether you mean a rough, poor neighbourhood or any type of residential area will often have to depend on context.

Different Latin American countries have different names for shanty towns. In Venezuela they are called 'ranchitos', although that may just mean the houses. In Peru they are euphemistically called 'pueblos jóvenes'! Others adopt the universally understood Brazilian word 'favela'.

[qgrande]

Thanks Chiri. So it is not a specific Dominicanism. Although I haven't heard Piantini or Naco referred to as 'mi barrio' often, I'm sure the neutral form does exist in the DR. What I mean, and please correct me if I'm wrong, is that as far as I know in Spain only the neutral meaning exists, and apparently in Mexico too. Any ideas on in which countries, apart from the DR, it also has the 'rough poor neighbourhood' meaning?

[montreal]

Puerto Rico

[Kyle]

you always here the DR1's saying "a barrio girl". so in fact it does serve two meanings...

[Victor Laszlo]

Originally Posted by qgrande

So, I wondered, is the use of 'barrio' with its meaning as a poor working class neighbourhood and negative connotations - as it is used frequently here in the forums - specifically Dominican, or are there more countries where it has that meaning?

The Dominicans and other Latinos I know use barrio simply to mean neighborhood. Pretty much all of the negative connotations I've encountered have come from non-Latinos.

Barrio has a history of usage among Anglos in the United States to mean Latino slum/ghetto neighborhoods in US cities. I think it's that negative usage that spills over onto this board.

Just out of curiousity, are you aware of any negative terms for Muslim communities say, in European cities?

[Chirimoya]

Originally Posted by Victor Laszlo

The Dominicans and other Latinos I know use barrio simply to mean neighborhood. Pretty much all of the negative connotations I've encountered have come from non-Latinos.

Barrio has a history of usage among Anglos in the United States to mean Latino slum/ghetto neighborhoods in US cities. I think it's that negative usage that spills over onto this board.

That just about sums it up. I think you are absolutely right.

[PICHARDO]

Originally Posted by qgrande

I did a search for 'barrio' in the Spanish101 section, and lots of references to 'barrio' as in 'barrio Spanish' vs. 'correct' Spanish, but what about the word barrio itself? Is the negative connotation a dominicanismo?
I knew that while in the DR 'barrio' and 'being from a barrio' has a negative connotation, in Spain 'barrio' has a more neutral meaning of 'neighbourhood' or urban district. I thought it was an Iberian vs. South American Spanish distinction.
But recently I spoke with some Mexican students and learned 'barrio' is a neutral word in Mexico too. And today I read Isabelle Allende (Chilean) writing about a childhood move to one of the wealthy upperclass 'barrios' of Santiago (de Chile), using that word.
So, I wondered, is the use of 'barrio' with its meaning as a poor working class neighbourhood and negative connotations - as it is used frequently here in the forums - specifically Dominican, or are there more countries where it has that meaning?
Just curious, and it's one of those words that can lead to faux pas in certain situations...

The term "Barrios" was used by the Spanish colonists here in the DR and stuck here since then.

It means to express a certain area as a whole district or neighborhood, plain and simple.

Villa Olga, a well to do area of well to do families is a "Barrio".
La Rinconada is a Barrio.
Los Cerros de Gurabo is a Barrio.

Now people tend to use "Sector" and "Residencial" to try and give luster to some of these over the other less well to do "Barrios" like Pekin and Pueblo Nuevo.

The Police use "Cuartel" as a definition of the area where they have a precinct of operations. So it was denoted in Cedulas before to have a "Cuartel/Barrio" denomination for some areas.

Barrio is just that, a residential area or cuartel!

[qgrande]

Originally Posted by Victor Laszlo

The Dominicans and other Latinos I know use barrio simply to mean neighborhood. Pretty much all of the negative connotations I've encountered have come from non-Latinos.

Barrio has a history of usage among Anglos in the United States to mean Latino slum/ghetto neighborhoods in US cities. I think it's that negative usage that spills over onto this board.

Very insightful. So it is a 'gringoism'.
I would have thought it had spilled over onto for instance Dominican newspapers as well, when writing of, say, 'problemas de drogas en los barrios'. But I can see that could be my reading that meaning into it after internalising the US-meaning of barrio.

Originally Posted by Victor Laszlo

Just out of curiousity, are you aware of any negative terms for Muslim communities say, in European cities?

Not somethng similar to that use of 'barrio' in the US. Of course there is a 'debate' over the presence of muslims in most European countries, and rising Islamophobia. But I know about that topic for only a couple of countries and languages. And the European Muslim population is made up of many different nationalities; Pakistani and Bangladeshi in the UK, Arabs in France and Spain, Turkish in Germany, etc., so there's many languages involved. There are many derogatory words for those nationalities.
Maybe in France, verlan (the inverse- word slang) has made the word 'beur' (phonetical inverse of 'arabe') quite well-known, but I don't think it has a negative meaning, really.

[Julio Tulio]

Nah to us it means $hithole,ghetto,etc....to the rest of the world it just means urban area.

Now "residencial" "ensanche" "urbanizacion" are more proper sounding to us.

Tell a dominican from the barrio he's from a barrio you'll most defintley get cursed out.

Dont ask me why...