Hey Chatburg,
I can't answer your question yet, but my Lady Friend & I will be staying at the CMA the 1st week of March. :~) Feel free to e-mail me after the 10th of March.
It's been several months since I made our reservations, but if memory serves the Club Miguel Angel upgrade was fairly inexpensive. Maybe US$30 per night. Seemed well worth it to me.
There are two good reviews and a link to another in Debbies Dominican website:
http://www.debbiesdominicantravel.com/travel4.html
The link is to a Cigar magazine review:
http://www.cigaraficionado.com/Cigar...12/fs1294.html
Enjoy,
Dan