as opposed to the "new" JD in the Metro/Villas del Mar area.
Actually we live in the very "center" of JD at the crossroads to Playa Juan Dolio and Los Conucos.
We like it here.....yes it has been VERY dead this year however it suits us as we "live" here as opposed to being tourists. There are still three good restaurants this end and a bar and a gym for workouts. The beach is great!! and the street quiet for bike rides,walking etc. (just not at night.....!) There is little crime except for "purse and jewellry " snatching but if you don't wear or carry any you're ok!

It's a very convenient area, close to the golf club,buses to SP or SD, taxi stand right across the street, two mini-markets plus the local colmados across the highway.
We have a car which makes it easier to get around but it really isn't necessary (more of a want than a need). We like to go with one of the area dive shops to Catalina and Saona a few times each year.
One question for you Golfer......you said you want to get a place to "winter". Isn't it kinda late this year to be looking? You really need to come down when it is winter to see what it's like.
There are a couple of condo's in our building that are rental units (mainly long term rentals) and from the tone of your posts I gather you're looking for a place that is fairly "Upscale" as opposed to middle of the road. This would be one of the places where you would feel more comfortable.
Yes prices are high in the area but I believe that is due to the fact that it IS a desirable area to be in. I've heard lots or things about other areas and that is one of the reasons we bought here (been here 12/13 yrs now).
The gov't has plans to revitalize the area (when is anyones guess-hopefully the PLD will be re-elected as it was their plan) however at present it looks like we'll soon have "Potable" water and they are in the proces of installing sewer lines also (when the sewer will function remains to be seen but water should be established in the next few weeks).
If you like I can give you phone # of rental units and you can call if your interested.